matrix-spec/specification/modules/instant_messaging.rst

.. Copyright 2016 OpenMarket Ltd
..
.. Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License");
.. you may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
.. You may obtain a copy of the License at
..
..     http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0
..
.. Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
.. distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
.. WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
.. See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
.. limitations under the License.

Instant Messaging
=================

.. _module:im:

This module adds support for sending human-readable messages to a room. It also
adds support for associating human-readable information with the room itself
such as a room name and topic.

Events
------

{{m_room_message_event}}

{{m_room_message_feedback_event}}

Usage of this event is discouraged for several reasons:
 - The number of feedback events will grow very quickly with the number of users
   in the room. This event provides no way to "batch" feedback, unlike the
   `receipts module`_.
 - Pairing feedback to messages gets complicated when paginating as feedback
   arrives before the message it is acknowledging.
 - There are no guarantees that the client has seen the event ID being
   acknowledged.


.. _`receipts module`: `module:receipts`_

{{m_room_name_event}}

{{m_room_topic_event}}

{{m_room_avatar_event}}

{{m_room_pinned_events_event}}

m.room.message msgtypes
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Each `m.room.message`_ MUST have a ``msgtype`` key which identifies the type
of message being sent. Each type has their own required and optional keys, as
outlined below. If a client cannot display the given ``msgtype`` then it SHOULD
display the fallback plain text ``body`` key instead.

Some message types support HTML in the event content that clients should prefer
to display if available. Currently ``m.text``, ``m.emote``, and ``m.notice``
support an additional ``format`` parameter of ``org.matrix.custom.html``. When
this field is present, a ``formatted_body`` with the HTML must be provided. The
plain text version of the HTML should be provided in the ``body``.

Clients should limit the HTML they render to avoid Cross-Site Scripting, HTML
injection, and similar attacks. The strongly suggested set of HTML tags to permit,
denying the use and rendering of anything else, is: ``font``, ``del``, ``h1``,
``h2``, ``h3``, ``h4``, ``h5``, ``h6``, ``blockquote``, ``p``, ``a``, ``ul``,
``ol``, ``sup``, ``sub``, ``li``, ``b``, ``i``, ``u``, ``strong``, ``em``,
``strike``, ``code``, ``hr``, ``br``, ``div``, ``table``, ``thead``, ``tbody``,
``tr``, ``th``, ``td``, ``caption``, ``pre``, ``span``, ``img``.

Not all attributes on those tags should be permitted as they may be avenues for
other disruption attempts, such as adding ``onclick`` handlers or excessively
large text. Clients should only permit the attributes listed for the tags below.
Where ``data-mx-bg-color`` and ``data-mx-color`` are listed, clients should
translate the value (a 6-character hex color code) to the appropriate CSS/attributes
for the tag.


:``font``:
  ``data-mx-bg-color``, ``data-mx-color``

:``span``:
  ``data-mx-bg-color``, ``data-mx-color``

:``a``:
  ``name``, ``target``, ``href`` (provided the value is not relative and has a scheme
  matching one of: ``https``, ``http``, ``ftp``, ``mailto``, ``magnet``)

:``img``:
  ``width``, ``height``, ``alt``, ``title``, ``src`` (provided it is a `Matrix Content (MXC) URI`_)

:``ol``:
  ``start``

:``code``:
  ``class`` (only classes which start with ``language-`` for syntax highlighting)


Additionally, web clients should ensure that *all* ``a`` tags get a ``rel="noopener"``
to prevent the target page from referencing the client's tab/window.

Tags must not be nested more than 100 levels deep. Clients should only support the subset
of tags they can render, falling back to other representations of the tags where possible.
For example, a client may not be able to render tables correctly and instead could fall
back to rendering tab-delimited text.

In addition to not rendering unsafe HTML, clients should not emit unsafe HTML in events.
Likewise, clients should not generate HTML that is not needed, such as extra paragraph tags
surrounding text due to Rich Text Editors. HTML included in events should otherwise be valid,
such as having appropriate closing tags, appropriate attributes (considering the custom ones
defined in this specification), and generally valid structure.

A special tag, ``mx-reply``, may appear on rich replies (described below) and should be
allowed if, and only if, the tag appears as the very first tag in the ``formatted_body``.
The tag cannot be nested and cannot be located after another tag in the tree. Because the
tag contains HTML, an ``mx-reply`` is expected to have a partner closing tag and should
be treated similar to a ``div``. Clients that support rich replies will end up stripping
the tag and its contents and therefore may wish to exclude the tag entirely.

.. Note::
   A future iteration of the specification will support more powerful and extensible
   message formatting options, such as the proposal `MSC1225 <https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix-doc/issues/1225>`_.

{{msgtype_events}}


Client behaviour
----------------

Clients SHOULD verify the structure of incoming events to ensure that the
expected keys exist and that they are of the right type. Clients can discard
malformed events or display a placeholder message to the user. Redacted
``m.room.message`` events MUST be removed from the client. This can either be
replaced with placeholder text (e.g. "[REDACTED]") or the redacted message can
be removed entirely from the messages view.

Events which have attachments (e.g. ``m.image``, ``m.file``) SHOULD be
uploaded using the `content repository module`_ where available. The
resulting ``mxc://`` URI can then be used in the ``url`` key.

Clients MAY include a client generated thumbnail image for an attachment under
a ``info.thumbnail_url`` key. The thumbnail SHOULD also be a ``mxc://`` URI.
Clients displaying events with attachments can either use the client generated
thumbnail or ask its homeserver to generate a thumbnail from the original
attachment using the `content repository module`_.

.. _`content repository module`: `module:content`_

Recommendations when sending messages
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

In the event of send failure, clients SHOULD retry requests using an
exponential-backoff algorithm for a
certain amount of time T. It is recommended that T is no longer than 5 minutes.
After this time, the client should stop retrying and mark the message as "unsent".
Users should be able to manually resend unsent messages.

Users may type several messages at once and send them all in quick succession.
Clients SHOULD preserve the order in which they were sent by the user. This
means that clients should wait for the response to the previous request before
sending the next request. This can lead to head-of-line blocking. In order to
reduce the impact of head-of-line blocking, clients should use a queue per room
rather than a global queue, as ordering is only relevant within a single room
rather than between rooms.

Local echo
~~~~~~~~~~

Messages SHOULD appear immediately in the message view when a user presses the
"send" button. This should occur even if the message is still sending. This is
referred to as "local echo". Clients SHOULD implement "local echo" of messages.
Clients MAY display messages in a different format to indicate that the server
has not processed the message. This format should be removed when the server
responds.

Clients need to be able to match the message they are sending with the same
message which they receive from the event stream. The echo of the same message
from the event stream is referred to as "remote echo". Both echoes need to be
identified as the same message in order to prevent duplicate messages being
displayed. Ideally this pairing would occur transparently to the user: the UI
would not flicker as it transitions from local to remote. Flickering can be
reduced through clients making use of the transaction ID they used to send
a particular event. The transaction ID used will be included in the event's
``unsigned`` data as ``transaction_id`` when it arrives through the event stream.

Clients unable to make use of the transaction ID are likely to experience
flickering when the remote echo arrives on the event stream *before*
the request to send the message completes. In that case the event
arrives before the client has obtained an event ID, making it impossible to
identify it as a remote echo. This results in the client displaying the message
twice for some time (depending on the server responsiveness) before the original
request to send the message completes. Once it completes, the client can take
remedial actions to remove the duplicate event by looking for duplicate event IDs.


Calculating the display name for a user
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Clients may wish to show the human-readable display name of a room member as
part of a membership list, or when they send a message. However, different
members may have conflicting display names. Display names MUST be disambiguated
before showing them to the user, in order to prevent spoofing of other users.

To ensure this is done consistently across clients, clients SHOULD use the
following algorithm to calculate a disambiguated display name for a given user:

1. Inspect the ``m.room.member`` state event for the relevant user id.
2. If the ``m.room.member`` state event has no ``displayname`` field, or if
   that field has a ``null`` value, use the raw user id as the display
   name. Otherwise:
3. If the ``m.room.member`` event has a ``displayname`` which is unique among
   members of the room with ``membership: join`` or ``membership: invite``, use
   the given ``displayname`` as the user-visible display name. Otherwise:
4. The ``m.room.member`` event has a non-unique ``displayname``. This should be
   disambiguated using the user id, for example "display name
   (@id:homeserver.org)".

   .. TODO-spec
     what does it mean for a ``displayname`` to be 'unique'? Are we
     case-sensitive?  Do we care about homograph attacks? See
     https://matrix.org/jira/browse/SPEC-221.

Developers should take note of the following when implementing the above
algorithm:

* The user-visible display name of one member can be affected by changes in the
  state of another member. For example, if ``@user1:matrix.org`` is present in
  a room, with ``displayname: Alice``, then when ``@user2:example.com`` joins
  the room, also with ``displayname: Alice``, *both* users must be given
  disambiguated display names. Similarly, when one of the users then changes
  their display name, there is no longer a clash, and *both* users can be given
  their chosen display name. Clients should be alert to this possibility and
  ensure that all affected users are correctly renamed.

* The display name of a room may also be affected by changes in the membership
  list. This is due to the room name sometimes being based on user display
  names (see `Calculating the display name for a room`_).

* If the entire membership list is searched for clashing display names, this
  leads to an O(N^2) implementation for building the list of room members. This
  will be very inefficient for rooms with large numbers of members. It is
  recommended that client implementations maintain a hash table mapping from
  ``displayname`` to a list of room members using that name. Such a table can
  then be used for efficient calculation of whether disambiguation is needed.


Displaying membership information with messages
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Clients may wish to show the display name and avatar URL of the room member who
sent a message. This can be achieved by inspecting the ``m.room.member`` state
event for that user ID (see `Calculating the display name for a user`_).

When a user paginates the message history, clients may wish to show the
**historical** display name and avatar URL for a room member. This is possible
because older ``m.room.member`` events are returned when paginating. This can
be implemented efficiently by keeping two sets of room state: old and current.
As new events arrive and/or the user paginates back in time, these two sets of
state diverge from each other. New events update the current state and paginated
events update the old state. When paginated events are processed sequentially,
the old state represents the state of the room *at the time the event was sent*.
This can then be used to set the historical display name and avatar URL.


Calculating the display name for a room
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Clients may wish to show a human-readable name for a room. There are a number
of possibilities for choosing a useful name. To ensure that rooms are named
consistently across clients, clients SHOULD use the following algorithm to
choose a name:

1. If the room has an `m.room.name`_ state event with a non-empty ``name``
   field, use the name given by that field.

#. If the room has an `m.room.canonical_alias`_ state event with a non-empty
   ``alias`` field, use the alias given by that field as the name.

#. If neither of the above conditions are met, a name should be composed based
   on the members of the room. Clients should consider `m.room.member`_ events
   for users other than the logged-in user, with ``membership: join`` or
   ``membership: invite``.

   .. _active_members:

   i. If there is only one such event, the display name for the room should be
      the `disambiguated display name`_ of the corresponding user.

   #. If there are two such events, they should be lexicographically sorted by
      their ``state_key`` (i.e. the corresponding user IDs), and the display
      name for the room should be the  `disambiguated display name`_ of both
      users: "<user1> and <user2>", or a localised variant thereof.

   #. If there are three or more such events, the display name for the room
      should be based on the disambiguated display name of the user
      corresponding to the first such event, under a lexicographical sorting
      according to their ``state_key``. The display name should be in the
      format "<user1> and <N> others" (or a localised variant thereof), where N
      is the number of `m.room.member`_ events with ``membership: join`` or
      ``membership: invite``, excluding the logged-in user and "user1".

      For example, if Alice joins a room, where Bob (whose user id is
      ``@superuser:example.com``), Carol (user id ``@carol:example.com``) and
      Dan (user id ``@dan:matrix.org``) are in conversation, Alice's
      client should show the room name as "Carol and 2 others".

   .. TODO-spec
     Sorting by user_id certainly isn't ideal, as IDs at the start of the
     alphabet will end up dominating room names: they will all be called
     "Arathorn and 15 others". Furthermore - user_ids are not necessarily
     ASCII, which means we need to either specify a collation order, or specify
     how to choose one.

     Ideally we might sort by the time when the user was first invited to, or
     first joined the room. But we don't have this information.

     See https://matrix.org/jira/browse/SPEC-267 for further discussion.

#. If the room has no valid ``m.room.name`` or ``m.room.canonical_alias``
   event, and no active members other than the current user, clients should
   consider ``m.room.member`` events with ``membership: leave``. If such events
   exist, a display name such as "Empty room (was <user1> and <N> others)" (or
   a localised variant thereof) should be used, following similar rules as for
   active members (see `above <active_members_>`_).

#. A complete absence of room name, canonical alias, and room members is likely
   to indicate a problem with creating the room or synchronising the state
   table; however clients should still handle this situation. A display name
   such as "Empty room" (or a localised variant thereof) should be used in this
   situation.

.. _`disambiguated display name`: `Calculating the display name for a user`_

Clients SHOULD NOT use `m.room.aliases`_ events as a source for room names, as
it is difficult for clients to agree on the best alias to use, and aliases can
change unexpectedly.

.. TODO-spec
  How can we make this less painful for clients to implement, without forcing
  an English-language implementation on them all? See
  https://matrix.org/jira/browse/SPEC-425.


Forming relationships between events
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

In some cases, events may wish to reference other events. This could be to form
a thread of messages for the user to follow along with, or to provide more context
as to what a particular event is describing. Currently, the only kind of relation
defined is a "rich reply" where a user may reference another message to create a
thread-like conversation.

Relationships are defined under an ``m.relates_to`` key in the event's ``content``.
If the event is of the type ``m.room.encrypted``, the ``m.relates_to`` key MUST NOT
be covered by the encryption and instead be put alongside the encryption information
held in the ``content``.


Rich replies
++++++++++++

Users may wish to reference another message when forming their own message, and
clients may wish to better embed the referenced message for the user to have a
better context for the conversation being had. This sort of embedding another
message in a message is known as a "rich reply", or occasionally just a "reply".

A rich reply is formed through use of an ``m.relates_to`` relation for ``m.in_reply_to``
where a single key, ``event_id``, is used to reference the event being replied to.
The referenced event ID SHOULD belong to the same room where the reply is being sent.
Clients should be cautious of the event ID belonging to another room, or being invalid
entirely. Rich replies can only be constructed in the form of ``m.room.message`` events
with a ``msgtype`` of ``m.text`` or ``m.notice``. Due to the fallback requirements, rich
replies cannot be constructed for types of ``m.emote``, ``m.file``, etc. Rich replies
may reference any other ``m.room.message`` event, however. Rich replies may reference
another event which also has a rich reply, infinitely.

An ``m.in_reply_to`` relationship looks like the following::

  {
    ...
    "type": "m.room.message",
    "content": {
      "msgtype": "m.text",
      "body": "<body including fallback>",
      "format": "org.matrix.custom.html",
      "formatted_body": "<HTML including fallback>",
      "m.relates_to": {
        "m.in_reply_to": {
          "event_id": "$another:event.com"
        }
      }
    }
  }


Fallbacks and event representation
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

Some clients may not have support for rich replies and therefore need a fallback
to use instead. Clients that do not support rich replies should render the event
as if rich replies were not special.

Clients that do support rich replies MUST provide the fallback format on replies,
and MUST strip the fallback before rendering the reply. Rich replies MUST have
a ``format`` of ``org.matrix.custom.html`` and therefore a ``formatted_body``
alongside the ``body`` and appropriate ``msgtype``. The specific fallback text
is different for each ``msgtype``, however the general format for the ``body`` is:

.. code-block:: text

  > <@alice:example.org> This is the original body

  This is where the reply goes


The ``formatted_body`` should use the following template:

.. code-block:: html

  <mx-reply>
    <blockquote>
      <a href="https://matrix.to/#/!somewhere:example.org/$event:example.org">In reply to</a>
      <a href="https://matrix.to/#/@alice:example.org">@alice:example.org</a>
      <br />
      <!-- This is where the related event's HTML would be. -->
    </blockquote>
  </mx-reply>
  This is where the reply goes.


If the related event does not have a ``formatted_body``, the event's ``body`` should
be considered after encoding any HTML special characters. Note that the ``href`` in
both of the anchors use a `matrix.to URI <../appendices.html#matrix-to-navigation>`_.

Stripping the fallback
``````````````````````

Clients which support rich replies MUST strip the fallback from the event before
rendering the event. This is because the text provided in the fallback cannot be
trusted to be an accurate representation of the event. After removing the fallback,
clients are recommended to represent the event referenced by ``m.in_reply_to``
similar to the fallback's representation, although clients do have creative freedom
for their user interface. Clients should prefer the ``formatted_body`` over the
``body``, just like with other ``m.room.message`` events.

To strip the fallback on the ``body``, the client should iterate over each line of
the string, removing any lines that start with the fallback prefix ("> ",
including the space, without quotes) and stopping when a line is encountered without
the prefix. This prefix is known as the "fallback prefix sequence".

To strip the fallback on the ``formatted_body``, the client should remove the
entirety of the ``mx-reply`` tag.

Fallback for ``m.text``, ``m.notice``, and unrecognised message types
`````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````

Using the prefix sequence, the first line of the related event's ``body`` should
be prefixed with the user's ID, followed by each line being prefixed with the fallback
prefix sequence. For example::

  > <@alice:example.org> This is the first line
  > This is the second line

  This is the reply


The ``formatted_body`` uses the template defined earlier in this section.

Fallback for ``m.emote``
````````````````````````

Similar to the fallback for ``m.text``, each line gets prefixed with the fallback
prefix sequence. However an asterisk should be inserted before the user's ID, like
so::

  > * <@alice:example.org> feels like today is going to be a great day

  This is the reply


The ``formatted_body`` has a subtle difference for the template where the asterisk
is also inserted ahead of the user's ID:

.. code-block:: html

  <mx-reply>
    <blockquote>
      <a href="https://matrix.to/#/!somewhere:example.org/$event:example.org">In reply to</a>
      * <a href="https://matrix.to/#/@alice:example.org">@alice:example.org</a>
      <br />
      <!-- This is where the related event's HTML would be. -->
    </blockquote>
  </mx-reply>
  This is where the reply goes.


Fallback for ``m.image``, ``m.video``, ``m.audio``, and ``m.file``
``````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````

The related event's ``body`` would be a file name, which may not be very descriptive.
The related event should additionally not have a ``format`` or ``formatted_body``
in the ``content`` - if the event does have a ``format`` and/or ``formatted_body``,
those fields should be ignored. Because the filename alone may not be descriptive,
the related event's ``body`` should be considered to be ``"sent a file."`` such that
the output looks similar to the following::

  > <@alice:example.org> sent a file.

  This is the reply


.. code-block:: html

  <mx-reply>
    <blockquote>
      <a href="https://matrix.to/#/!somewhere:example.org/$event:example.org">In reply to</a>
      <a href="https://matrix.to/#/@alice:example.org">@alice:example.org</a>
      <br />
      sent a file.
    </blockquote>
  </mx-reply>
  This is where the reply goes.


For ``m.image``, the text should be ``"sent an image."``. For ``m.video``, the text
should be ``"sent a video."``. For ``m.audio``, the text should be ``"sent an audio file"``.


Server behaviour
----------------

Homeservers SHOULD reject ``m.room.message`` events which don't have a
``msgtype`` key, or which don't have a textual ``body`` key, with an HTTP status
code of 400.

Security considerations
-----------------------

Messages sent using this module are not encrypted, although end to end encryption is in development (see `E2E module`_).

Clients should sanitise **all displayed keys** for unsafe HTML to prevent Cross-Site
Scripting (XSS) attacks. This includes room names and topics.

.. _`E2E module`: `module:e2e`_
.. _`Matrix Content (MXC) URI`: `module:content`_