You cannot select more than 25 topics Topics must start with a letter or number, can include dashes ('-') and can be up to 35 characters long.

rav/proposal/otks_in_upload_order

erikj/sync_v2_state_after

main

old_master

johannes/rich-room-topics

include_device_keys

tulir/service-members

travis/msc/safety-allow-errors-on-unbind

matthew/msc4220

dbkr/threepid_submittoken_errors

toger5/expiring-events-keep-alive

matthew/msc4016

kegan/profile-changes

travis/msc/widgets-send-recv-toDevice

andybalaam/owner-state-events

toger5/matrixrtc-call-ringing

andybalaam/crypto-terminology

tulir/remove-legacy-mentions

travis/msc/deprecated-endpoints

tulir/appservice-to-device

anoa/copy_hints

element-hq/oidc-qr-login

hughns/matrixrtc-m-call

hughns/delegated-oidc-architecture

quenting/account-deeplink

quenting/as-device-management

toger5/matrixRTC

clokep/profile-tz

erikj/sss

travis/msc/mention-spam-suppress

travis/msc/translated-errors

kegan/ssext-receipts

toger5/future-widget-api

tulir/send-redact-backwards-compatibility

kegan/otk-reset

aggregation-cleanup

toger5/rtc-focus-well-known

travis/msc/request-max-body-size

kegan/fallback-keys

travis/msc/room-labeling-filtering

rei/msc/accdata_ases

travis/msc/social-sign-on-authed-media

hughns/device-signing-upload-uia

travis/msc/verified-accounts-part1

tulir/fix-reply-intentional-mentions

travis/msc/t2bot/bot-buttons

travis/msc/head-media-download

travis/msc/fix-x-matrix-auth

babolivier/m_locked

matthew/msc4136

travis/msc/remove-qs-auth

hughns/gha-update

travis/msc/voluntary-flagging

travis/reinstated-events

travis/msc/appservice-soft-failure

hughns/simple-rendezvous-capability

travis/msc/feature-versioning

matthew/msc4103

kegan/fix-threaded-read-receipts

travis/msc/media-integrity

travis/msc/signing-key-purpose

travis/msc/media-redirect-auth-cdn

toger5/localTimestamp-server-sync

toger5/encrypted-event-indexing

kegan/complement-msc

justjanne/3981-relations-recursion

matthew/msc3018

travis/msc/delivery-receipts

giomfo/push_encrypted_events

kegan/msc3884

stefan/pusher-creation

travis/msc/2244-ext-uia

matthew/msc4083

gsouquet/unsigned-thread-id

andybalaam/event-thread-and-order

hs/proposal-admin-contact-1

matthew/msc4076

kegan/sync-v3

rav/proposal/dead_device_key_claims

giomfo/tweak_email_notification

travis/msc/inhibit-profile

travis/msc/rules-prompt

travis/msc/mutable-events

travis/msc/additive-events

travis/msc/rbac-pl

clokep/mentions-mixin

travis/msc/room-id-is-create-event

travis/msc/send-as-server-or-room

travis/msc/room-send-key

travis/msc/make-send-pdu

hughns/sso-redirect-action

travis/msc/drop-ips

travis/msc/strict-user-id-grammar

travis/msc/iana/service_name

andybalaam/thread-root-is-not-in-thread

andybalaam/deleting-state

hs/shared-rooms

babolivier/relation_redaction

weeman1337/voice-broadcast

travis/msc/polls-notifs

alfogrillo/poll_history_cache

travis/msc/room-model-config

kegan/pseudo-ids

bwindels/relation-redactions

clokep/thumbnail-media-negotiation

dbkr/voip-completed-elsewhere

madlittlemods/gappy-timelines

dbkr/2746-fix-typos

dbkr/msc2746

hughns/login-token-requests

clokep/encrypted-mentions-only-rooms

travis/msc/enc-as/otk-query

travis/msc/inline-widgets

travis/msc/voice-messages

travis/msc/extev/translatable

travis/msc/extev/video

travis/msc/extev/images

travis/msc/extev/files

travis/msc/extev/audio

travis/msc/extev/encryption

travis/msc/extev/notices

travis/msc/extev/emotes

madlittlemods/forwards-fill

hughns/device-scope-txnid

madlittlemods/join-timestamp-massaging

madlittlemods/timestamp-to-event-causality-parameter

matthew/msc2716

madlittlemods/createroom-timestamp-massaging

madlittlemods/power-level-up

kerry/display-notification-reason

travis/msc/linearized-matrix

hughns/sign-in-with-qr

kegan/ssext-account-data

kegan/ssext-typing

andybalaam/dynamic-predecessor

travis/msc/enc-as/key-query

travis/msc/otk-dl-appservice

hs/as-txn-limit

hughns/x25519-secure-channel

travis/msc/ietf-mimi-framework

hs/reporting-fixes

hughns/sign-in-with-qr-v2

kerry/remote-local-notification-toggle

madlittlemods/dynamic-predecessor

johannes/event-match-dotted-keys

dbkr/msc2747

clokep/room-tag-notifications

matthew/msc1767

matthew/msc3277

kegan/msc3885

SimonBrandner/msc/sfu

matthew/group-voip

kerry/remote-push-toggle

kerry/user-agent-on-device

travis/msc/extev/push-rules

travis/msc/extev-rel/push-rule-feature-condition

travis/msc/extev-rel/bulk-push-rule-change-endpoint

travis/msc/extev/rver-cond

travis/msc/audio-waveform

SimonBrandner/msc/call-notif

hs/appservice-no-notifs

travis/msc/del-srv

travis/msc/ietf-mimi-transport

travis/msc/ietf-mimi-message-format

fayed/cryptographic-membership

eric/msc-jump-to-date

rav/proposal/linking_media_to_events

matthew/owner-pl

madlittlemods/appservice-interested-in-local-users

justjanne/messages-endpoint-threads-filter

rav/propsal/content_tokens_for_media

matthew/msc1763

rav/proposal/faster_joins

fayed/tofu

babolivier/m_not_approved

rei/unable_partial_state_room

travis/msc/custom-stickers

babolivier/user_status

johannes/event-match-almost-anything

babolivier/msc_presence_busy

travis/msc/welcome-message

anoa/blurhash

hs/errcode-specific-failure

anoa/custom_room_presets

travis/msc/federated-reports

aggregations-references

travis/extev/power-levels

johannes/cascading-profile-tags

richvdh-patch-1

travis/clarify-msc/aggregations-on-sync

clokep/threads-push-rule

andybalaam/owned-state

travis/msc/v10

matthew/location-streaming

stefan/ephemeral-location-streaming

andybalaam/location-streaming-wip

rav/pr_templates

rav/readme

hawkowl/backfill-state

kerry/time-based-push-filtering

johannes/notify-in-app

erikj/deprecate_sender_key

babolivier/unread_counts

travis/msc/state-change-acls

andybalaam/state-sub-keys

hs/deactivated-user-metadata

gsouquet/threading-via-relations

neilalexander/plints

travis/msc/soft-logout-flows

travis/msc/simplified-join-rules

rav/no_preview_proposals

hs/fix-as-login-typo

rav/update_deps

rav/missing_changelog

rav/clarify_send_join

warning-untagged

release/v1.2

neilalexander/powerlevels

anoa/numbers

matthew/typos

matthew/msc3676

stefan/encrypted-ephemeral-data-units

rav/fix_appservice_threepid_protocols

rav/empty_response_body_fixes

matthew/location

hs/widget-share-api

rav/allof-comments

dbkr/voip-early-media

gsouquet/from-param-msc3567

travis/msc/extev/replies-edits

neilalexander/msc/send

rav/proposal/drop-event-from-auth-events

release/v1.1

hs/appservice-login-spec

rav/fix_array_examples

shay/clarify_well_known

rav/fix_event_auth_spec

uhoreg/remove_room_message_feedback

hs/as-global-read

bwindels/aggregation-pagination

bwindels/relations-visibility

rav/update_validator

rav/fix_netlify_for_plus_branch

rav/move_prev_content

rav/fix_up_notifications

travis/msc/timeboxed-relations-endpoint

rav/remove_unsigned_from_federation_events

anoa/emote_clarifications

matthew/let-users-kick-each-other

rav/remove_event_def

hs/explicitly-link-RFC5870

kegan/spaces-summary

rav/no_rebuild_matrix.org

rav/netlify_previews

rav/del_bk_pipeline

rav/remove_old_templated

rav/fix_gen_swagger

matthew/guest-state-events

kegan/low-bandwidth

travis/msc/encrypted-state

hs/synthetic-appservice-events

daenney/msc-server-status

travis/msc/upgrade-state

dmr/remove_mentions_of_groups

travis/msc/widgets-send-receive-events

rav/pagination_conventions

rav/master2

neilalexander/binary

rav/pagination_clarifications

rav/api_conventions

anoa/spec_release_infra

rav/docstyle_json_properties

rav/doc_style

rav/readme_updates

dkasak/tweak-pdu-diagram

dkasak/newsfragment-for-3339

hs/widget-invite-api

anoa/duplicate_mimetype_info

erikj/counters

kitsune/counting-unread-messages

fix-croatian-sas-emoji

hs/proposal-appservice-login

travis/msc/modal-widgets

j94/members-knock

jryans/mobile-toc-overlap

hs/explicit-room-id-for-tombstones

travis/msc/space-flair

hs/soft-kicks

clokep/batch-state

anoa/clarify_concerns_during_fcp

matthew/msc1772

travis/msc/trees

message-timezone-markup

dbkr/msc3144

rav/fix_pdu_size

rav/proposals/id_grammar

travis/msc/uia-fix-optional

dbkr/voip_asserted_identity

matthew/msc2962

travis/msc/mutable-subtypes

babolivier/msc-room-label

anoa/test

travis/msc/typed-typing-notifs

dbkr/i_felt_your_presence

anoa/room_version_7

matthew/matrix-uri

matthew/msc3020

travis/msc/tos-api

travis/msc/widgets-http-transport

travis/msc/widgets-scoped

anoa/support-rendered-data

travis/msc/widgets-re-exchange-caps

travis/msc/member-apis-event-id

travis/msc/widgets-navigate-permission

msc-connect-matrix-to-matrix

travis/msc/1337-joined-rooms

kegan/msc/threading

matthew/msc2753

travis/msc/widget-client-identification

travis/msc/move-widget-title

travis/widgets

travis/msc/widget-caps-respond

matthew/msc2444

travis/msc/global-event-ids

dbkr/msc2845

uhoreg/keys_withheld

dbkr/msc2772

clokep/test-pusher

travis/msc/widgets-data-error

travis/msc/widget-id

rav/proposals/notification_attributes

travis/msc/roles

neilalexander/identities

matthew/msc2775

babolivier/device_lists_clients

rav/remove_oauth2

travis/msc/ipfs

travis/msc/thumbnail-types

travis/msc/mxc-deduplication

travis/msc/media-ids

travis/msc/rudimentary-media-auth

jryans/matrix-to-uri-v2

jryans/get-event-by-id

rei/pushrules_define_enabled

rei/bug_type_actions

hs/msc-bridge-inf

matthew/msc2278

rav/proposal/mark_unread

travis/msc/impl-guide

server_server/release-r0.1.4

client_server/release-r0.6.1

kegan/backfill-wording

ben/captions-proposal

poljar/event-id-required

benp/proposals-scraper-fix

anoa/gpdr17

giomfo/tagged_events

anoa/media_as_rooms

matthew/msc1777

babolivier/identity-versions

babolivier/msc_email_case

anoa/no_auth_on_submit_token

anoa/no_client_secret

rav/proposal/fix_alias_redaction

rav/proposal/change_aliases_auth_rules

anoa/msc_media_information_api

anoa/msc_separate_hs_api

hs/msc-as-versions2

hs/msc-as-versions

jryans/clarify-cross-signing-examples

erikj/invite_reject_reasons

matthew/msc2326

msc2313

matthew/msc2359

hs/msc-2356

client_server/release-r0.6.0

identity_service/release-r0.3.0

matthew/msc2228

travis/msc/integrations/base

matthew/msc2301

matthew/2326

rav/proposal/remove_mxids_from_events

travis/msc/integrations/select-none

travis/msc/immutable-dms

travis/msc/kill-msisdn-pw-reset

matthew/msc2300

babolivier/standardised-federation-response-format

msc2271

matthew/msc2270

poljar/key_request_fix

dbkr/tos_2

dbkr/is_in_account_data

travis/msc/rejoin-private-rooms

anoa/msc2233

anoa/msc2322

travis/msc/upgraded-private-rooms

hs/hash-identity

travis/msc/third-party-power

anoa/is_store_hashed_3pids

matthew/msc1849

server_server/release-r0.1.3

application_service/release-r0.1.2

push_gateway/release-r0.1.1

matthew/msc1849-rewrite

anoa/test_pr

jryans/msc-push-rule-reactions

jryans/room-one-to-one-push-rule

anoa/typooo

identity_service/release-r0.2.1

travis/msc/federation-capabilities

client_server/release-r0.5.0

server_server/release-r0.1.2

identity_service/release-r0.2.0

application_service/release-r0.1.1

anoa/hs_3pid_tokens

matthew/1.0/msc688-msc1227-lazy-loading

matthew/msc1779

bwindels/messages-chunk-order

anoa/clarify_email_sending

rav/proposal/no_trailing_slash_on_key_request

babolivier/password-policy

matthew/room_v4

dbkr/dummy_auth_for_disambiguation

hs/disable-presence

anoa/missing_punctuation3

anoa/typo2

anoa/typo

anoa/missing_punctuation

rav/fix_jenkins_comments

neilj/Remove-prev_content-from-the-essential-keys-list2

travis/msc/integrations/stickerpicker

neilj/Remove-prev_content-from-the-essential-keys-list

rav/proposal/no_slash_in_event_id

neilj/v3_rooms_by_default

uhoreg/fix_export_format

erikj/unbind_threepid_msc

hs/proposal-admin-contact

travis/msc/cancel-3pid-sessions

babolivier/alttext-sticker

anoa/add_space

benpa/spelling-fix

erikj/fed_invite_error_code

matthew/msc1796

server_server/release-r0.1.1

server_server/release-r0.1.0

erikj/event_id_hashes

neilj/remove_presence_lists

neilj/msc-remove-presence-lists

neilj/msc_remove_presence_lists

erikj/make_membership_room_ver

dbkr/encrypted-recovery-keys

travis/msc/profile-discovery

anoa/sticky_headers_fix

matthew/msc1769

matthew/msc1776

rav/proposal/cs_capabilities

erikj/state_res_rejections

erikj/rooms_v2

erikj/event_checks

revert-1730-rav/proposal/cs_api_in_login

dbkr/add_sandbox_to_csp

rav/msc1730/work

rav/simplify_msc1730

rav/proposals/homeserver_in_sso_login

rav/proposal/signing_signing_keys

erikj/soft_logout

travis/msc/wellknown-improvements

erikj/soft_fail

matthew/encrypted-recovery-keys

travis/misc/room-spec-full

travis/notes/3pid-invites

matthew/device_list_update

matthew/to-device

client_server/release-r0.4.0

identity_service/release-r0.1.0

erikj/limit_auth_events

erikj/auth_events

erikj/auth_rejections

erikj/spec_3pid_ruls

erikj/fixup_auth_rules

application_service/release-r0.1.0

push_gateway/release-r0.1.0

human-id-rules

erikj/limit_txn_size

hs/guests-can-fetch-events

dbkr/room_tag_grammar

drafts/e2e

erikj/state_res_msc

dbkr/fix_room_tags

hs/dns-to-be-hostname

anoa/openapi_3

benp/clarifyintro

anoa/as_thirdparty_lookup

travis/proposals-pagination

benpa/travisci-ignore-proposals

hs/appservice-use-auth.type

t3chguy/errs

t3chguy/erase

t3chguy/group_id

matthew/filter_members

michaelkaye/re_add_proposals

benparsons/proposalsCI

t3chguy/search_docs

rxl881/stickerpack

proposals

rav/test

rxl881/stickers

rooms/event

dbkr/fix_keys_changes

dbkr/keys_query_token

client_server/r0.3.0_updates

dbkr/is_bulk_lookup

dbkr/threepid_add_msisdn

rav/travis

client_server/r0.2.0_updates

rav/projects-guillotine

babolivier/fix-invite-example

babolivier/third-party-invites

babolivier/fix-get-room-alias

leonerd/circle

dbkr/remove_unused_is_file_2

dbkr/remove_unused_is_file

markjh/thumbnail_url

markjh/replays

paul/thirdparty-lookup

dbkr/push_examples_api_path

erikj/report

dbkr/identity_api_right_path

dbkr/notifs_api

erikj/filter_url

rav/access_tokens

dbkr/clarify_highlight_and_sound

matthew/fix_state_sending_desc

dbkr/contains_display_name_override

dbkr/add_dot

markjh/filename

release/client-server/r0.2.0

erikj/account_deactivate

dbkr/more_requesttokens

dbkr/dont_line_wrap_rst

dbkr/threepid_requesttoken

erikj/presence

dbkr/default_state_defaults

drafts/reinstate_device_push_rules

rav/json_schema

paul/update-howto-for-r0

paul/migrating-from-v1

dbkr/fix_directory_path

dbkr/get_pushers

dbkr/add_push_change_event_id

markjh/pushrule_stream

dbkr/notification_counts

markjh/change_action

markjh/get_enabled

dbkr/fix_meta_escaping

markjh/default_rules

markjh/remove_device_specific_rules

dbkr/profile_return_null

markjh/3pid_login

markjh/three_pid_creds

invalid_user_name

erikj/create_room_3pid_invite

markjh/guest_access

markjh/account_data_filters

markjh/room_filter

markjh/wildcards

paul/federation

erikj/search_yet_agian

markjh/filter_inline

erikj/event_context_api

markjh/archived_flag

markjh/client_config

markjh/room_tags

more_nesting

markjh/syntax_highlighting_message_examples

markjh/full_http_api_docs

markjh/v2_sync_prev_content

markjh/request_syntax_highlighting

erikj/search

markjh/event_syntax_highlighting

erikj/login_fallback_v1

templating-nested-request-objects

erikj/search_actual

markjh/list_formatting

markjh/blockquote_css

clarify_scale_crop

appservice-swagger

spec-182-asapi-user-creation

registration-swagger

invite-room-state

room-avatar

proofing

proofing2

module-history-vis

module-im

spec-177-events-max-len

spec-207-asapi-unique-tokens

erikj/newline_gendoc_STOP_BEING_CRANKY

spec-205-password-strength

directory-api

spec-144-https-examples

module-push

data-messages

html-messages

markjh/initial_sync_archived_flag

markjh/v2_sync_templating

markjh/v2_sync_api

erikj/disable_federation

release-0.2.0

module-presence

module-content-repo

erikj/room_create_preset

module-receipts

module-voip

module-typing2

spec-feature-profiles

erikj/invite_state

paragraphs

erikj/login_token

spec-module-format

unused-template-vars

macaroons

markjh/check_request_schema

markjh/node_swagger_validator

spec-restructure-modules

convert-to-modules

markjh/document_v1_rooms_api

markjh/jenkins

markjh/example_checker

markjh/codehighlighting

markjh/swagger_examples

markjh/event-schema

spec-file-structure

spec-edits-cleanup

markjh/gendoc_directory

client_server_v2_http_api

newlines

receipts

markjh/history_for_rooms_that_have_been_left

history_visibility

erikj/canonical_alias

csauth2

templating

event-schemas

as-register-modifications

erikj/as-register-removal

key_v2_fixes

csauth

key_v2

ua925_reshuffle

push

v2-presence

application-services

use-cases

client_server_v2

push_gateway/r0.1.0

r0.0.0

0.2.0

application_service/r0.1.0

application_service/r0.1.1

application_service/r0.1.2

client-server/r0.1.0

client-server/r0.2.0

client-server/r0.3.0

client_server/r0.4.0

client_server/r0.5.0

client_server/r0.6.0

client_server/r0.6.1

identity_service/r0.1.0

identity_service/r0.2.0

identity_service/r0.2.1

identity_service/r0.3.0

push_gateway/r0.1.1

r0.0.1

server_server/r0.1.0

server_server/r0.1.1

server_server/r0.1.2

server_server/r0.1.3

server_server/r0.1.4

v1.1

v1.2

2.9 KiB

Raw Blame History

MSC3987: Push actions clean-up

There are two defined push rule actions which are of dubious use:

coalesce is defined, but unused in the spec and not implemented on any homeservers ¹ or clients ² beyond validating it or treating it identically to notify.
dont_notify is a no-op, but frequently used as a way to denote do nothing. It is clearer to provide an empty list of actions to avoid a situation where additional actions are given with it, e.g. ["notify", "dont_notify"] is currently valid, but does not make sense. ³

Proposal

The coalesce push rule action is removed from the Matrix specification.

The dont_notify push rule action is deprecated. Homeservers and clients should ignore it. Any pre-defined rules which include the dont_notify action are redefined to have an empty list of actions:

.m.rule.master
.m.rule.suppress_notices
.m.rule.member_event

It is recommended that homeservers continue accepting the coalesce and dont_notify actions, but ignore them during processing. (Treating them as no-ops.) A future Matrix spec version should remove them completely.

Potential issues

A client might attempt to create a push rule with a coalesce or dont_notify action that homeservers will reject as an unknown action.

Alternatives

Do nothing and continue propagating confusion.

Security considerations

None.

Dependencies