diff --git a/CHANGELOG b/CHANGELOG
index 2c41057bf..57a7f4a97 100644
--- a/CHANGELOG
+++ b/CHANGELOG
@@ -1,6 +1,7 @@
 CHANGELOG Roundcube Webmail
 ===========================
 
+- Fix PHP warning when responding to a message with many Return-Path headers (#1489136)
 - Fix unintentional compose window resize (#1489114)
 - Fix performance regression in text wrapping function (#1489133)
 - Fix connection to posgtres db using unix socket (#1489132)
diff --git a/program/steps/mail/func.inc b/program/steps/mail/func.inc
index 0845bf738..47800564c 100644
--- a/program/steps/mail/func.inc
+++ b/program/steps/mail/func.inc
@@ -1803,9 +1803,12 @@ function rcmail_identity_select($MESSAGE, $identities = null, $compose_mode = 'r
     // Try Return-Path
     if ($from_idx === null && ($return_path = $MESSAGE->headers->others['return-path'])) {
         foreach ($identities as $idx => $ident) {
-            if (strpos($return_path, str_replace('@', '=', $ident['email_ascii']).'@') !== false) {
-                $from_idx = $idx;
-                break;
+            $ident = str_replace('@', '=', $ident['email_ascii']) . '@';
+            foreach ((array)$return_path as $path) {
+                if (strpos($path, $ident) !== false) {
+                    $from_idx = $idx;
+                    break 2;
+                }
             }
         }
     }