diff --git a/astrid/plugin-src/com/todoroo/astrid/reminders/Notifications.java b/astrid/plugin-src/com/todoroo/astrid/reminders/Notifications.java
index 41286fd7d..18ee80574 100644
--- a/astrid/plugin-src/com/todoroo/astrid/reminders/Notifications.java
+++ b/astrid/plugin-src/com/todoroo/astrid/reminders/Notifications.java
@@ -72,15 +72,17 @@ public class Notifications extends BroadcastReceiver {
 
         Resources r = context.getResources();
         String reminder;
-        if(type == ReminderService.TYPE_DUE || type == ReminderService.TYPE_OVERDUE)
-            reminder = getRandomReminder(r.getStringArray(R.array.reminders_due));
-        else if(type == ReminderService.TYPE_ALARM)
+
+        if(type == ReminderService.TYPE_ALARM)
             reminder = getRandomReminder(r.getStringArray(R.array.reminders_alarm));
-        else if(type == ReminderService.TYPE_SNOOZE)
-            reminder = getRandomReminder(r.getStringArray(R.array.reminders_snooze));
-        else if(Preferences.getBoolean(R.string.p_rmd_nagging, true))
-            reminder = getRandomReminder(r.getStringArray(R.array.reminders));
-        else
+        else if(Preferences.getBoolean(R.string.p_rmd_nagging, true)) {
+            if(type == ReminderService.TYPE_DUE || type == ReminderService.TYPE_OVERDUE)
+                reminder = getRandomReminder(r.getStringArray(R.array.reminders_due));
+            else if(type == ReminderService.TYPE_SNOOZE)
+                reminder = getRandomReminder(r.getStringArray(R.array.reminders_snooze));
+            else
+                reminder = getRandomReminder(r.getStringArray(R.array.reminders));
+        } else
             reminder = ""; //$NON-NLS-1$
 
         synchronized(Notifications.class) {