diff --git a/proposals/3813-obfuscated-events.md b/proposals/3813-obfuscated-events.md index 2d19da663..c594e35ed 100644 --- a/proposals/3813-obfuscated-events.md +++ b/proposals/3813-obfuscated-events.md @@ -1,23 +1,5 @@ # MSC3813: Obfuscated events - - Currently, event content can be end-to-end encrypted, but the metadata cannot. This means that if someone inspects the Matrix homeservers, they can see in what rooms one is most active, and at what time they are most active. @@ -28,35 +10,6 @@ imitate the structure of two-sided conversations. ## Proposal - ### Introduction ### Events @@ -121,47 +74,12 @@ Clients MUST negotiate to exchange obfuscated events before sending the keepaliv ## Potential issues -*Not all proposals are perfect. Sometimes there's a known disadvantage to implementing the proposal, -and they should be documented here. There should be some explanation for why the disadvantage is -acceptable, however - just like in this example.* - -Someone is going to have to spend the time to figure out what the template should actually have in it. -It could be a document with just a few headers or a supplementary document to the process explanation, -however more detail should be included. A template that actually proposes something should be considered -because it not only gives an opportunity to show what a basic proposal looks like, it also means that -explanations for each section can be described. Spending the time to work out the content of the template -is beneficial and not considered a significant problem because it will lead to a document that everyone -can follow. - ## Alternatives -*This is where alternative solutions could be listed. There's almost always another way to do things -and this section gives you the opportunity to highlight why those ways are not as desirable. The -argument made in this example is that all of the text provided by the template could be integrated -into the proposals introduction, although with some risk of losing clarity.* - -Instead of adding a template to the repository, the assistance it provides could be integrated into -the proposal process itself. There is an argument to be had that the proposal process should be as -descriptive as possible, although having even more detail in the proposals introduction could lead to -some confusion or lack of understanding. Not to mention if the document is too large then potential -authors could be scared off as the process suddenly looks a lot more complicated than it is. For those -reasons, this proposal does not consider integrating the template in the proposals introduction a good -idea. - ## Security considerations - - The events MUST be sent in end-to-end encrypted rooms. @@ -170,14 +88,6 @@ events in the room. ## Unstable prefix - - Please use `moe.kazv.mxc.msc.obfuscated-events` as the unstable prefix. ## Dependencies